Category Archives: Bulletins and Newsletters

ESHC News

Tenants & Neighbors Hosts Panel Discussion: Legislative Organizing: How to Win in Albany!

Monday, September 13th, 7:00 – 9:00 PM
Community Service Society, Room 4A
105 East 22nd Street at Park Avenue South

Featuring members and advocates from:

• New York City Aids Housing Network
• Housing Conservation Coordinators
• Domestic Workers United
• And More!

The tenant movement faced many challenges this year, but our fight to strengthen the rent laws continues! Join us as we learn from advocates and organizers who have had successful legislative campaigns this year, who will share their insights on how to win state-level legislative campaigns for social and economic justice despite the challenging political landscape in Albany.

To RSVP or for more info, contact Mary Tek, Rent Regulation Organizer at Tenants & Neighbors:

212-608-4320 x 316 or email: mtek@tandn.org

Critics Root for Espada’s Exit, but He’s Dug In

The New York Times

9-2-10

In a former video store turned campaign office along the Grand Concourse in the Bronx, signs denouncing the area’s state senator cover the dingy windows. “Westchester’s Worst Legislator,” one poster proclaims, a dig at Senator Pedro Espada Jr. who has been persistently accused of living in a home he owns in Mamaroneck, which is in Westchester and is not part of his district.

The man who opened the office is Bill Samuels, a top Democratic donor from Manhattan who has pledged up to $250,000 to defeat Mr. Espada in the Sept. 14 primary. He is part of an army of opponents that has descended on the northwest Bronx to try to topple Mr. Espada, the Senate majority leader, who is facing civil corruption charges.

If this longtime political survivor is going down, there are a lot of people who want to help dig his grave.

The Working Families Party, which aspires to be the state’s most powerful third party, says it plans to spend $100,000 on the race and has been sending busloads of paid canvassers to climb Bronx high-rises reciting Mr. Espada’s sins. Union officials have knocked on thousands of doors promoting Mr. Espada’s chief rival.  Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/03/nyregion/03espada.html?_r=1&ref=todayspaper

In Latest Battle for Control of Stuyvesant Town, the Tenants Are Wooed

The New York Times

9-2-10

The last time the mammoth Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village complexes were sold, their tenants were largely ignored. Now, two lending groups battling in court for control of the sister complexes on the East Side of Manhattan are both trying to curry favor with the 25,000 residents.

Which lender will control the complexes remained up in the air on Thursday after a hearing in State Supreme Court in Manhattan, where the rival lenders squabbled over the meaning of a creditor agreement. The judge in the case, Richard B. Lowe III, said he would soon rule in the matter. But that decision is almost certain to be appealed, real estate lawyers and analysts say.

In the meantime, the lending groups — CW Capital on the one hand, and a partnership of Winthrop Realty Trust and the hedge fund Pershing Square Capital on the other — say that they are acting in the interest of the tenants. The lenders also say they embrace the tenants’ demand for the creation of an “affordable” co-op that covers all 11,226 apartments in 110 buildings between 14th and 23rd Streets, east of First Avenue.  Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/03/nyregion/03stuytown.html?_r=1&ref=todayspaper

Lack of fines for violations lets slumlords terrorize tenants

NYDailyNews.com

8-31-10

Slumlords can let their tenants stew in moldy, unheated, rat-infested, garbage-filled hellholes without facing any real consequences, critics charge. “They are gaming the system,” said city Public Advocate Bill de Blasio, who Monday released an online slumlord watch list. The Watch List is online at:  http://advocate.nyc.gov/landlord-watchlist
“When you or I get a parking ticket, we have to pay,” de Blasio said. “When a landlord gets a violation for a health and safety problem, they ignore it in many cases and then they ignore it and then they
ignore it again.”  Most housing violations for leaks, pests or trash do not have fines attached, frequently forcing tenants to bring landlords to Housing Court to get action – but that can take years, advocates say.  Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/2010/08/31/2010-08-31_slumlords_are_playing_dirty_so_well_play_hardball_say_city_pols.html

Using Private Eyes to Keep Track of Tenants

The New York Times

8-30-10

As a parade of slovenly dressed 20-somethings passed through the entrance of a downtown Manhattan apartment building on a weekday afternoon, these seemingly savvy New Yorkers did not seem to notice they were the subjects of a photo shoot. That is because this shoot was covertly orchestrated by their landlord, who had hired a private investigator to root out illegal tenants.

Masked by lunchtime crowds and afternoon rain, the private eye, Joseph Mullen, who has run a sleuthing firm for more than 40 years, parked his car in front of the building, flipped through papers showing that several residents of the seven-story building were “dead or living somewhere else,” and waited.  Shane Williams, a vice president of the firm, J.T. Mullen Inc., slouched strategically in his seat and photographed people as they entered and left. The affable pair looked like observers at an anti-fashion show as food deliverymen paraded through, an older portly renter stepped out to buy cheese biscuits and renters dressed in gym clothing shuffled outside to smoke.

“We don’t know half the people who live in this building,” Mr. Mullen said. He released a gravelly chuckle, rustled through papers and glanced through the tinted window. “The landlords say, ‘I got to get these illegal tenants out and make some money.’ ” Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/31/nyregion/31appraisal.html?_r=1&ref=todayspaper

Got loud neighbors? Talk to the judge

NY Daily News

8-27-10

Because the mayor’s noise code doesn’t address neighbor noise, the process of evicting a loud tenant falls on the landlord or co-op or condo board. According to the rental managers working for big developers, complaints start the process of quieting a loud neighbor.

If friendly requests and notes slipped under doors begging for peace and quiet don’t work, complaints to landlords begin the next phase of addressing the nuisance.  Landlords must send a letter to the loud
party, requesting quiet. If those go unanswered or ignored, a suit to evict the tenant can begin, but the landlord must show written documentation and a string of attempts to quiet the guilty party.

“Housing code regulations say tenants are allowed ‘peaceful enjoyment’ after 10 p.m.,” says Kevin Coughlin, the general manager at Truffles Tribeca. “To evict someone for noise, we have to show a
paper trail of complaints. Then, we can seek a court order for eviction. Even then, it’s still up to the judge.”  Read more:
http://www.nydailynews.com/real_estate/2010/08/27/2010-08-27_got_loud_neighbors_talk_to_the_judge.html#loop1

Tenants Group: Some Senate Dems Betrayed Us

New York Observer

8-13-10

The pro-rent regulation folks are upset.  Last night, Tenants PAC, a group devoted to expanding rent regulations in New York, sent out a press release announcing that it was rescinding endorsements for three Senate Democrats from outside the city: David Valesky, Brian Foley, and Darrel Aubertine. The group had pushed to get all three elected over Republicans, but now it is, by its telling, finding them resistant to expanded tenant protections.

The display of displeasure toward the three Democrats seems to stem from last week’s legislative session, when some of the more liberal Democrats in the Senate pushed for votes on a number of tenant protection bills, only to see them fail when there were not enough votes in the conference. The powerful landlord lobby opposed these bills, and urged its friends in the Democratic conference to oppose them as well.

“It was clear to those of us in the Senate gallery that evening that the Senate Democratic leadership attached no importance to our issues, and that their promises to deliver for tenants meant nothing,” Mike McKee, a longtime tenant activist who has pushed legislation in Albany, said in a statement announcing the rescinded endorsements. “After tramping around in the snow in Oswego for several days to help the Democrats win control of the Senate, I felt that this was a terrible betrayal.”

All helps illustrate how the landlords, who have become generous campaign contributors to Democrats, have had more success than many imagined in warding off any expansions of tenant regulations in the Democratic-controlled Senate. (For decades, until 2009, Republicans, who followed a pro-landlord agenda, had controlled the chamber.) This has frustrated tenant groups, who are now scrambling to get a scaled-back package through Albany.  Read more: http://www.observer.com/politics?page=1

Newsletter Updates

Daily News
3-20-10
34% more homeless people sleeping on New York City streets than last year, survey shows
New York experienced a 34% surge in the number of homeless people on city streets last year – the first increase in five years, according to data released Friday. The city counted 3,111 people sleeping on streets and in subways during its annual survey of the homeless this January – 783 more than last year. Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/2010/03/20/2010-03-20_34_more_people_on_streets_than_last_year_findings_show.html#ixzz0irjANKn1

Developer ignores building codes, deadly fall balcony not inspected in 10 years
The owners of the building where a young social worker plunged to his death from a faulty balcony haven’t filed an inspection report of its exterior in 10 years, officials said.  Under city law, owners of buildings seven stories or higher are required to hire engineers to inspect their balconies every five years.  Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/2010/03/20/2010-03-20_deadly_fall_balcony_not_inspected.html#ixzz0irkLDCd8

Metropolitan Council on Housing
3-19-10
 
Rent Guidelines Board 2010 Schedule Available 
The NYC Rent Guidelines Board has published its schedule of public meetings in 2010. To view the schedule, visit their website: http://housingnyc.com/html/about/meetings.html
 
Volunteers Needed For Tenants’ Rights Hotline!
Met Council on Housing’s tenants’ rights hotline is one of the most important services we offer for tenants who are in need of assistance in getting repairs, fighting landlord harassment, dealing with eviction, and organizing tenant associations. Needless to say, our phones are ringing off the hook!
 
We need more volunteers to help answer questions about tenants’ rights. You do not need to be knowledgeable already about housing issues in order to volunteer; we will train you. We only ask that you share an interest in helping tenants and be able to commit to a regular weekly slot during our hotline hours. Met Council’s tenants’ rights hotline operates Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays from 1:30pm to 5pm. If you’re interested in volunteering, contact Mario at 212-979-6238, extension 207, or email:  mario@metcouncil.net
 
Our Town
3-18-10
Change in Subway Blasting Rattles East Siders
Residents along Second Avenue have been accustomed to blasting during subway construction. But while the noise was minimal and kept to a low rumble during the day, blasts have been getting louder and happening during the evening, according to residents of the East 90s. Read more:  http://ourtownny.com/2010/03/17/change-in-subway-blasting-rattles-east-siders/

The Village Voice
3-16-10
New York’s Ten Worst Landlords, Part 1
How many bad landlords are there in New York City? Who can count that high? But we can count to 10, so we assembled this group of really bad landlords—listed in no particular order—only after months of research. We combed through records of unresolved violations, lawsuits, eviction notices, and court documents. We spent thousands of hours in deeply depressing apartments and interviewed wave after wave of equally gloomy tenants. We also talked with scores of landlords, city bureaucrats, prosecutors, defense attorneys, housing advocates, and others. In the end, these are the 10 landlords we would want to rent from the least. Read more: 
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-03-16/news/new-york-s-ten-worst-landlords/

January 2010 ESHC Newsletter

 

 

The ESHC Newsletter is a monthly publication of the East Side Housing Coalition, a volunteer grassroots organization dedicated to protecting tenant’s rights & to providing a voice for fair housing practices in New York City’s East Side Neighborhoods.

 

Electoral Advocacy: 
What it is and why it’s so important in 2010
We were so confident at the beginning 2009 that having a Democratic majority in the NYS Senate would mean seeing the housing bills passed by the Assembly become a reality on the floor of the Senate. Sadly, that was not to be.  A critical factor in the chaos that took place in Albany was the precious but narrow majority that Democrats held—only TWO seats. Unfortunately, our legislature’s partisan process of doing business meant that each and every Democrat had to be on board in order for many bills to pass. This November, our state legislators are up for re-election, so we must act NOW to put legislators in office who will vote our way. For those who live in Manhattan, this means going outside our districts to educate others on the issues. It means making phone calls, writing letters, and actually campaigning in districts where legislators do not support the housing bills. To get involved, please email: e.sidehousingcoalition@gmail.com

 

Upcoming Housing Events:
Co-op/Condo Forum
Wednesday, February 17, 6:00 to 8:00 PM
Baruch College (CUNY) – School of Public Affairs
135 East 22nd Street (Room 301)
Senator Liz Krueger & Assembly Member Brian Kavanagh invite owners to have their questions answered on NYS & NYC laws, co-op & condo by-laws, the roles of boards, and shareholders’ rights by attorneys Lucas Ferrara of Finkelstein Newman Ferrara; Kevin McConnell of Himmelstein, McConnell, Gribben, Donoghue & Joseph; and Lisa Wallace, Assistant Attorney General, Real Estate Finance Bureau.  Reservations are not required. For information, email Alice Fisher at alicefisher.nyc@gmail.com, or call 212.490.9535.

 

ESHC Launches Co-op/Condo Owners Program
The Program will educate owners on their legal rights, teach them necessary skills to protect those rights, and help them organize in order to affect legislation.  A meeting will be held on Thursday, February 25th to select a steering committee of owners who will dedicate their time and expertise to this important initiative. If you are interested in serving on the steering committee, please email a summary of your experience and the issues you face as an owner to: e.sidehousingcoalition@gmail.com

 

Landlord Faces Lawsuit for Harassment
NY Times
State Attorney General Andrew M. Cuomo announced Thursday that he intends to sue a major New York landlord (Vantage Properties) that he says harassed hundreds of tenants in rent-regulated apartments in Queens and Manhattan in a systematic effort to force their departure to create vacancies for higher-paying tenants. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/29/nyregion/29vantage.html?ref=nyregion

 

Tishman Speyer Properties/BlackRock Realty
$5.4B NY Housing Complexes Go to Creditors

The financially troubled owners of two massive apartment complexes that sold for a record $5.4 billion a few years ago said they’re turning them over to their creditors. The ownership team led by Tishman Speyer Properties and BlackRock Realty couldn’t make a multimillion-dollar loan payment earlier this month for the Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village apartments in Manhattan. http://www.dailyfinance.com/article/owners-54b-ny-housing-complexes-go-to/847370?flv=1

 

Tenants and Neighbors Help Tenants Win
Lawsuit against Rent Guideline Board
The tenant movement won a major victory when the NYS Supreme Court ruled that the NYC Rent Guidelines Board exceeded their authority when they determined that tenants who have lived in their apartments for 6 years or longer and whose rent is under $1,000 a month should pay higher rent increases than all other rent stabilized tenants. Tenants & Neighbors was a plaintiff in the lawsuits filed against the RGB in 2008 and 2009 by the Legal Aid Society and the South Brooklyn Legal Services.  http://tandn.org/

 

Metropolitan Council on Housing Phone Campaign: 
Say NO to Espada as Housing Chair in 2010!

At the urging of the Met Council, hundreds of tenants called Senate Democratic Leader John Sampson’s office to tell him that Pedro Espada must not be made chair of the Senate Housing Committee in 2010.  They asked Sampson to appoint a member who will pass rent reform legislation this year, including the repeal of vacancy decontrol.  Tenants were asked to report their results to:  active@metcouncil.net

 

2010 Tenant Priority Bills:
In January 2009, the NYS Assembly passed tenant protection bills which went to the State Senate’s Committee on Housing, Construction and Community Development, Chaired by Pedro Espada Jr. Unfortunately, the bills became captive to the Senate’s political upheaval in June, and went nowhere.  The tenant priority bills for 2010 are the same as 2009, but have been assigned new numbers.
 
A.1688  Repeals the 1971 Urstadt Law, and by doing so, would restore full home rule powers over rent and eviction laws to the New York City Council and Mayor.
 
A.860     Luxury Decontrol: Would raise rent-stabilization rent and income thresholds from $2,000 monthly rent and $175,000 AGI annual household income to $2,700 rent and $240,000 AGI annual income, above which rents are no longer rent-stabilized.
 
 A.1928  Makes rent increases for Major Capital Improvements (MCI) a temporary and separately listed surcharge, which allows landlords to re-coup the cost of a building-wide improvement over a period of 7 years.
 
A.2005    Repeals vacancy decontrol in NYC and some suburban counties which removed an estimated 300,000 apartments from rent and eviction protections and would re-regulates 90 to 95 percent of the apartments that have been vacancy decontrolled in the past 15 years.
 
We expect landlords to step up their lobbying against the tenants’ reform package.  The ESHC, in coalition with other tenant advocacy organizations, must fight to get pro-tenant legislation through the Senate.  To achieve our mission of preserving and expanding rent-regulated housing, we must build a critical mass of committed activists.  We rely on our members to form this critical mass and to help lobby in Albany, make phone calls and write letters.  To get involved, please email us at:  e.sidehousingcoalition@gmail.com

 

Tenant Resources
 
City Wide Taskforce on Housing Court:  212.962.4795.  www.cwtfhc.org
 
Department of Housing & Community Renewal (DHCR) http://www.dhcr.state.ny.us/ 
General Info:  718.739.6400
DHCR:  To find email addresses & telephone numbers: http://www.dhcr.state.ny.us/AboutUs/contact.htm#phone
 
DHCR Fact Sheets:  www.dhcr.state.ny.us/Rent/FactSheets/
 
Eviction Intervention Services:  212.308.2210
http://eisny.org/services.html
 
Housing Conservation Coordinators:   212.549.5996
www.hcc-nyc.org/legalservices/housinglinks.htm
 
Lenox Hill Neighborhood House’s Legal Advocacy and Organizing Department:  212-744-5022 ext.1392
http://www.lenoxhill.org/content/who-we-help/legal-advocacy-and-organizing.html
 
Metropolitan Council on Housing:  www.metcouncil.net
Hotline:  212-979-0611 (M, W- F, 1:30 to 5 PM)
 
Tenants Political Action Committee (PAC):  212.577.7001 http://tenantspac.org/
 
Tenants & Neighbors:  Tel:  212-608-4320 www.tenantsandneighbors.org/
 
Tenant Net:  Provides online resources:  http://tenant.net/
 
ESHC Community Outreach
The ESHC is reaching out to East Side churches, synagogues and community organizations to ask them to distribute our newsletters to their congregations or members.  We need assistance with our outreach and appreciate your help. To volunteer, please email: e.sidehousingcoalition@gmail.com

Tishman Speyer Properties/BlackRock Realty Owners: $5.4B NY Housing Complexes Go to Creditors

Daily Finance
1-25-10

The financially troubled owners of two massive apartment complexes that sold for a record $5.4 billion a few years ago said Monday they’re turning them over to their creditors.  The joint venture ownership team led by Tishman Speyer Properties and BlackRock Realty, hurt by the real estate market collapse, couldn’t make a multimillion-dollar loan payment earlier this month for the Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village apartments in Manhattan.

Over the last few days it became clear the only viable alternative to bankruptcy would be to transfer to lenders control and operation of the 110 buildings and 11,000 apartments overlooking the East River, partnership spokesman Bud Perrone said.
“We make this decision as we feel a battle over the property or a contested bankruptcy proceeding is not in the long-term interest of the property, its residents, our partnership or the city,” Perrone said in an e-mailed statement.

The group bought the complexes, which have about 25,000 tenants, in 2006 at the height of the real estate bubble in the nation’s largest residential real estate deal.  The record purchase price seemed outrageous to many real estate analysts, but the partnership believed it had a winning strategy: It would aggressively convert thousands of rent-regulated apartments occupied by middle-class families into luxury units that would fetch top dollar.

Read more at:
http://www.dailyfinance.com/article/owners-54b-ny-housing-complexes-go-to/847370?flv=1

Ruling Could Mean Lower Rents for 300,000!

The New York Times
1-26-10
By CARA BUCKLEY
 
To most renters in New York City, it sounds like a modest, even enviable, rent increase: Pay an additional $45 if your monthly rent happened to be less than $1,000 and you had been living in the same apartment for more than six years.
 
But to the City Council, and advocates for New York’s lower-paying tenants, the increase issued by the city’s Rent Guidelines Board in 2008 amounted to what they called a “poor tax.” And in a ruling last week, Justice Emily Jane Goodman of State Supreme Court in Manhattan agreed. Should the ruling stand — the city plans to appeal it — some 300,000 rent-stabilized tenants could receive rebates and small reductions in their rent.
The ruling stemmed from the rent increases approved by the city’s Rent Guidelines Board in 2008. The board allowed landlords of rent-subsidized apartments to raise rents by 4.5 percent for one-year leases, and 8.5 percent for two-year leases.
The board also passed a minimum increase for anyone who had been living in an apartment for more than six years: They would have to pay at least $45 and $85 for one- and two-year leases, respectively. This meant that any long-term tenant paying less than $1,000 a month would be faced with a higher percentage increase than other rent-stabilized tenants. The rule was called Order No. 40. 
 
Read more at: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/26/nyregion/26rent.html?ref=todayspaper

Tenants Win Lawsuit Against RGB!

The tenant movement won a major victory on Friday when the New York State Supreme Court ruled that the New York City Rent Guidelines Board (RGB) exceeded their authority when they determined that tenants who have lived in their apartments for six years or longer and whose rent is under $1,000 a month should pay higher rent increases than all other rent stabilized tenants. Tenants & Neighbors was a plaintiff in the lawsuits filed against the RGB in 2008 and 2009 by Legal Aid Society and South Brooklyn Legal Services.

The tenant attorneys who filed the lawsuit relied on a successful lawsuit Tenants & Neighbors previously filed against the Nassau County RGB, in which the courts ruled that the RGB did not have the authority to create a separate rate adjustment guidelines based on factors related to the tenants, not to the type of housing accommodation.  Read more at:  http://tandn.org/